Editorial: Ass-backward Thinking About SIU’s Fiscal Emergency

More Articles
Editorial: A Case for Neighborhood Business Zoning in Carbondale
Editorial: A Eulogy for Glenn Poshard
Editorial: A Great Trustees Decision— But a High Cost to the Low Price?
Editorial: A Wary Sister Campus Rejects Carbondale
Editorial: Blame SIU Enrollment for Carbondale’s Property Tax Increases
Editorial: Brad Cole’s Solution for State-university Funding
Editorial: Concealed Carry: Safeguards Illinois Must Adopt
Editorial: Demons Are Exorcized, and Carbondale’s on a Roll!
Editorial: Don Monty— Call the Question
Editorial: Endless Fall(ing) Enrollment
Editorial: Enrollment, Enrollment, Enrollment: Down, Down, Down
Editorial: Get Happy! The Festivities of Fall Arrive en Masse
Editorial: Glenn Poshard’s Army: Will He Mobilize SIU? Will He?
Editorial: How Far Will SIU Enrollment Fall (Again)?
Editorial: How to Rebuild SIU Enrollment Part I
Editorial: How to Rebuild SIU Enrollment, Part II: Improve the Quality of Life
Editorial: How to Rebuild SIU Enrollment, Part III
Editorial: Rebuilding SIU Enrollment, Part IV
Editorial: Rules for Writing Science Fiction and Fantasy
Editorial: Sending a Message to Potential Immigrants: Carbondale Has Your Back:
Editorial: Shame on Illinois Democrats
Editorial: SIU Alumni: Your Alma Mater Needs Your Help
Editorial: SIU Enrollment Goes Down Again
Editorial: SIU Enrollment Goes Down Again, Hard; Freshman Enrollment May Not Be at a Twenty-year High
Editorial: SIU Enrollment Springs Toward Disaster. Again.
Editorial: SIU’s Low, Low College Scorecard Grade Point Average and A Shift in the Balance of Power at SIU?
Editorial: SIU’s Nauseating Enrollment Numbers and the Sickening Administrative Spin
Editorial: SIU’s Stupid Tuition Hike
Editorial: SOS (Save Our Strip): Message Received?
Editorial: Taxes, Jobs, and Leadership: Three Connected Southern Illinois Conundrums
Editorial: Tell the General Assembly to Let Voters Elect SIU’s Trustees
Editorial: The Phantom Menace— The Real Threat SIU Faces
Editorial: Three Trains Running, But for How Long?
Editorial: To Rebuild Enrollment, Make SIU Fun Again
Editorial: Towed Away
Editorial: Unintended Consequences of Hitting the Publish Button
Editorial: Wake up, SIU! Take Action in the State Budget War
Editorial: Why the Decision to Shop Locally Should Be More Than Just a Good Intention
Editorial— Complacency: SIU’s Doomsday Scenario
Editorial— Enrollment: Knocked Down, Can Dunn Get It Back Up?
Editorial— F.B.I. Tries to Nab Santa’s List; PATRIOT Act Invoked to Find Terrorist Suspects
Editorial— Further Freeing the Weed: Keeping Carbondale Kinder and Mellower
Editorial— Killing Illinois’s Universities: How Bruce Rauner Can Get Away With Murder
Editorial— Police Academy: Learning to Cope with Video
Editorial— Poshard and Cheng: Pathetic Excuses for SIU’s Enrollment Death Spiral
Editorial— Rauner on Campus: The Proper Reaction
Editorial— Rules for Radicals: Lessons for the May 2 Strike Committee from Saul Alinsky
Editorial— S.O.S.: Save Our Strip (And How We Got in This Terrible Mess)
Editorial— SIU Enrollment in Context: Worse Than Almost Everybody Else
Editorial— SIU Football: Beat Liberty or Leave Town
Editorial— SIU’s 2015 College Score Card
Editorial— SIU’s Budget Woes and Local Elections: The Connection Between Two Big Local Stories
Editorial— Splash of Cold Water: Tell Rauner to Resume Work on the Super Splash Park
Editorial— Thoughts About Tim Beaty’s Murder
Editorial— Total Eclipse: SIU Is in the Dark

Two weeks ago, SIU system president Randy Dunn told WSIU-FM that the Carbondale campus has “been liv
Chris Wissmann

Two weeks ago, SIU system president Randy Dunn told WSIU-FM that the Carbondale campus has “been living for many years with a structural deficit that hasn’t been corrected. In the most simplistic way possible, describing it as having too many programs for now too few students.”

It’s extremely difficult to argue that the Carbondale campus, which has ever-fewer students to serve, isn’t overstaffed.

Between 1991 and 2015, SIU lost about thirty percent of its enrollment. But during that same time (counting the School of Medicine and excluding graduate assistants and undergraduate employees), the total number of faculty and staff declined by only about ten percent.

In addition to having far fewer students paying tuition and fees, the university is in Gov. Bruce Rauner’s fiscal stranglehold. Rauner has refused to sign a budget for almost two years, choking off state funding for higher education and social services, among other essential government functions. As a result, SIU is looking down the barrel of a $50 million budget cut.

No reasonable person can doubt the math— in the short run, SIU must contract, despite the painful human and economic toll that will take. The budget axe will fall on people who aren’t remotely responsible for the crisis, and that’s not fair, but it may need to happen if the institution will survive to recover and eventually rebuild.

(Layoffs and rebuilding, however, must take place in a strategic fashion. Cuts must come from places that students have abandoned. Upon restoration of sanity in the governor’s mansion, probably two long years from now, SIU probably shouldn’t simply reinstate programs and positions it eliminated during this crisis. Instead, SIU should look to institute new, innovative curricula where it can reasonably expect enrollment growth, perhaps by looking to what the job market demands but other state universities aren’t providing.)

That said, Dunn described the dilemma backward. It’s not that SIU has too many programs for too few students. SIU has too few students for the programs it offers. It’s a distinction with a serious difference.

The way Dunn put it, the way to right the ratio of students to programs is to eliminate programs and the personnel who run them. If he’s thinking about the immediate future, again, that may prove necessary. Nevertheless, while Dunn has a responsibility to face the financial crisis head-on, in doing so he cannot completely demoralize his employees and students or the surrounding area.

Of course, there’s another path forward, one that will tip the balance in far more favorable ways toward everyone in the SIU community— dramatically increase enrollment.


By more publicly charting that course, Dunn would at least give hope that SIU can, in fact, rebound. Right now, however, that leadership is as necessary as it appears absent.